Burch to Fahy: “You Are Not Invited, End of Story”

April 6, 2010

senator_the_hon__lt__col_david_a__burch__obe__jp__ed_1The controversy continues over the ‘Bermudian only’ meeting set by Colonel David Burch, with Bermuda Democratic Alliance Chairman and international business employee Michael Fahy voicing his objection, stating that Colonel Burch told him he could not attend.

Minister of Immigration Senator Lt. Col. David Burch sent out an email in mid March setting a meeting to discuss term limits for guest workers. Colonel Burch stated that only Bermudians who work in international business can attend, and ID must be shown to prove Bermudian status.

Mr Fahy works at a senior level in international business, employed by Marsh IAS, the largest captive management company in the world. Locally the company employs approximately 150 people, including Mr Fahy who is Vice President and General Counsel.

Mr Fahy told us he emailed the Colonel saying he would attend the meeting in his capacity as an international business employee, and he was subsequently dis-invited.

Bernews asked Colonel Burch about this situation, and the Colonel confirmed that he dis-invited Mr Fahy.

Below is the full email trail:

From: Fahy, Michael
Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 11:07 PM
To: Bermudians In International Business
Subject: Re: invite

I will be there on the 8th.

Thanks

Michael M Fahy

From: Burch, David
Sent: Monday, March 29, 2010 8:27 AM
To: Fahy, Michael
Subject: RE: invite

You are not invited to this meeting.

From: Fahy, Michael
Sent: Monday, March 29, 2010 10:37 AM
To: Burch, David; Bermudians In International Business
Subject: re: invite

Dear Minister Burch

I would be grateful if you would explain why this open invitation is now being retracted.

For the avoidance of doubt I am in international business and unless there is a solid justification for the withdrawal of the invitation then I should be able to attend on the 8th in my capacity as General Counsel of IAS in Bermuda.

Regards

Michael M. Fahy

From: Burch, David
Sent: Tuesday, March 30, 2010 6:49 AM
To: Fahy, Michael
Subject: RE: invite

My meeting – I get to decide who attends.

From: Fahy, Michael
Sent: Tuesday, March 30, 2010 5:03 PM
To: Bermudians In International Business; Burch, David
Subject: RE: invite

Dear Minister Burch

With respect, your invitation was to Bermudians in international business and it did not say anything about any particular Bermudians in international business being excluded or that you were going to pick which Bermudians in international business could or could not attend the meeting. Thus I look forward to attending on 8th April 2010.

Regards

Michael M. Fahy

From: Burch, David
Sent: Tuesday, March 30, 2010 5:13 PM
To: Fahy, Michael
Subject: RE: invite

I am not in the habit of justifying my actions to people like you – it is my meeting and I get to decide who is invited – you are not invited – end of story.

Mr Fahy told us that “Minister Burch’s invitation retraction is inexcusable” and went on to explain that he can only assume the invitation is being retracted due to his beliefs and/or political opinions which he says seems to be a direct contravention of the Human Rights Act [HRA] of 1981.

Mr Fahy stressed that he is a legitimate member of the international business community, as Counsel and VP in a captive management company, and also mentioned that “the notice itself was likely a contravention of the HRA by discriminating against others based on national origin in excluding non-Bermudians.”

Stressing the fact that he is not just being petty, Mr Fahy said it concerns him on a wider scale, saying “His behaviour is an affront to democracy and demonstrates the lengths that will be taken to quell dissention or those that question the Minister. The phrase “people like you” is terrible – it is not right and the Minister should apologise”

The meeting had already been a point of contention with a member of another political party, with UBP Senator Michael Dunkley requesting to attend, and being told by Senator Burch he cannot, as he does not work in international business.

Both Mr Fahy and Senator Dunkley have stated their intentions to attend the meeting this upcoming Thurs Apr 8 at the Berekely Institute despite being not invited, which should provide for an interesting exchange at the door.

Share via email

Read More About

Category: All, News, Politics

Comments (3)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

Articles that link to this one:

  1. Defiance and Domination | April 6, 2010
  1. AJ says:

    Why would Minister Burch take so long to decide to reject Mr. Fahy from attending the meeting? Maybe it is a coincidence that this rejection is the very next working day after Mr. Fahy wrote an opinion piece in the Bermuda Sun criticising the Minister's personal wish that Bermudians be permitted to have one foreign spouse and not be allowed another if you are divorced from them. Julian Hall said it best indeed - a PR train wreck in slow motion. I am glad Mr. Fahy stood up - for far too long so many of us fear reprisal for speaking up at injustices such as these.

    Like(22)
    Dislike(4)
  2. CB says:

    It is nothing less than outrageous that Burch should ask for the IB sector's input and then decide exactly who from IB should attend. Burch has gone too far. Will he next decide that only 'those who look like me' can attend? You disgust me Burch!! Even more than you disgusted me before.

    Like(36)
    Dislike(2)

Sign Up For Our Free Email Newsletters

email-banners-good-news-370

Latest Podcasts

Podcast: Martha Dismont On Child Neglect/Abuse

Podcast: Martha Dismont On Child Neglect/Abuse

In the latest Bernews podcast, we sit down with Martha Dismont, the Executive Director of the Family Centre, which has recently launched a campaign called ‘Neglect Is Abuse, See It, Stop It’ to try and stem a significant rise in cases of child neglect.

Ms Dismont links the rise in neglect cases directly “to the conditions we are seeing in Bermuda”, “particularly the rise in unemployment among locals”.

“Parents are stressed and therefore not really able to think about these issues that [...]

Share via email
September 23, 2016 | 2 Comments
Podcast: Baron On Crime, Road Safety & More

Podcast: Baron On Crime, Road Safety & More

In this latest Bernews podcast, we speak to the Minister of National Security Jeff Baron who revealed than gang membership has dropped by more than 150 people. Yet, he says, gangs are still changing and recruiting – sometimes even from schools.

The Minister talks about his plans for restorative justice – which focuses on both the needs of the victim as well as the offender, plus the community that is involved.

Mr Baron talks about his stance on policing in St. George’s and stands [...]

Share via email
August 30, 2016 | 8 Comments
Podcast: Governor On Airport, Commission, More

Podcast: Governor On Airport, Commission, More

In this latest Bernews podcast, we interview George Fergusson who will soon be stepping down as Governor.

He touches on a wide range of issues such as turning down a request to hold a Commission of Inquiry into the Tucker’s Point land matter, the airport redevelopment, the effect on Bermuda of Brexit, the British Government’s stance on slave trade reparations and more.

And Mr Fergusson re-iterated his belief that the Commission of Inquiry into issues highlighted by the Auditor General’s reports was [...]

Share via email
July 25, 2016 | 9 Comments
Podcast: MP Furbert On Same Sex Marriage Bill

Podcast: MP Furbert On Same Sex Marriage Bill

Bermuda is on “good grounds” regarding same sex marriage, based on what other countries around the world have done, according to MP Wayne Furbert.

Mr Furbert — who tabled amendments to ensure marriage was enshrined as being between a man and a woman — was responding during a Bernews podcast interview to a statement from the Human Rights Commission.

He refuted that for many – the recent referendum failed to attract 50 per cent of those eligible to vote – same sex [...]

Share via email
July 14, 2016 | 53 Comments
Podcast: Ross Webber & Sean Moran Of BDA

Podcast: Ross Webber & Sean Moran Of BDA

What does International Business means to Bermuda and what role does the Bermuda Business Development Agency [BDA] play? That is the question we looked at during our most recent Podcast, where Chris Famous sits down with Ross Webber and the Sean Moran of the BDA.

Ross Webber joined the BDA as CEO in 2014, having served as a Board Director since inception, while Sean Moran is a Business Development Manager at the BDA, a role he has held since August 2014.

The BDA [...]

Share via email
July 7, 2016 | 0 Comments