Gibbons: ‘Parliament Should Have Been Informed’

May 18, 2012

Following reports that Government signed a multi million contract with PHC in 2008, Government moved to clarify the issue saying that the finances being distributed are solely dependent on the PHC facility being completed, while Opposition MP Dr Grant Gibbons said Parliament should have been informed at the time the agreement was signed.

Yesterday the RG reported that, “The Ministry of Education has agreed to pay PHC as much as $10 million, spread over a 20-year period, in usage fees for schools in the zone to use the club’s $4 million multi-dimensional complex.”

The statement in response from Government said, “This morning the Ministry of Education moved to ensure clarity regarding reports in yesterday’s and today’s Royal Gazette surrounding the Ministry’s financial commitment to Pembroke Hamilton Club (PHC).

“Regrettably the stories have caused some concern in the community. And the Ministry wishes to clarify that it is not committed to provide any funds to the PHC until such time that their facility is completed and public school students have access to it.

“The Ministry further advised that there was a contract signed in 2008 and the finances being distributed are solely dependent on a completed PHC facility.”

Opposition MP Dr Grant Gibbons questioned why the “significant commitment of taxpayer funds” was not disclosed by the Minister during Budget Debates in previous years, and said Parliament should have been informed when the agreement was signed.

Dr Gibbons said, “If as reported in the RG, the Ministry of Education signed a 20 year $10 million lease with PHC in 2008, then we have to ask why this significant commitment of taxpayer funds was not disclosed by the Minister during Budget Debates in the last few years?”

“A commitment of this magnitude would have a material impact on Ministry spending over a 20 year period and Parliament should have been informed, at the time the agreement was signed.

“The Minister needs to provide a full explanation, including details of the lease and any other commitments that Government may have given to PHC or related parties.

“How this matter has been handled and the apparent lack of disclosure to Parliament is yet another issue that the Public Accounts Committee may wish to review,” concluded Dr Gibbons.

Share via email

Read More About

Category: All, News, Politics

Comments (12)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Chart says:

    So how many other sweetheart insider deals of this magnitude are lurking in Government desk drawers?

    Like(0)
    Dislike(0)
    • terry says:

      Please don't tell me this will be a Cup Match draw..................

      Like(0)
      Dislike(0)
  2. Hmmmmm says:

    Hold on a second Doc. Not a penny has been paid out or spent. The agreement is to pay a fee for service once the thing is built. The last time I checked, ain't nothing but grass growing there at PHC so this "committment" cannot be accounted for because it doesn't exist until something else happens, which is clearly years away. There is nothing in this.And just because Dr. Gibbons doesn't know doesn't make it illegal or otherwise. There is NO requirement for the House or anyone else for that matter to be informed. "Move along folks, there's nothing to see here...". Next.

    Like(0)
    Dislike(0)
    • Just the Facts says:

      Not so fast. We know you're anxious to sweep things under the rug, but Gibbons is right. Signing any contract obligates this government and any future government to its terms, and since this isn't the government's money, it's the people's money, the Minister in 2008 should have brought this to the attention of the people through either an announcement or the Budget statement. We're not quibbling about illegal here, just asking that this government do the right and proper thing. It's called good governance, something that the current PLP government has chosen to pretty much ignore since it's been in office. Besides, secrecy does make you wonder. If there's nothing to see here, then there's no reason it shouldn't have been disclosed originally.

      Like(0)
      Dislike(0)
    • Pastor Syl says:

      @ Hmmmmm: Audited reports should contain some mention of contingency expenses - I don't know the correct term - but some way to acknowledge that there is a responsibility to pay out monies if and when certain conditions are met.

      Also, it isn't just Dr. Gibbons who needs to know, per se, it is all of us. That is OUR money that is being promised, and those in the House are, supposedly, trusted custodians of OUR money and therefore have a RIGHT to know everything that is happening with OUR money, and to ask those difficult questions that you apparently don't like to hear.

      A "transparent" government would have told us so the question wouldn't have had to be asked at all.

      Like(0)
      Dislike(0)
      • pepper says:

        Pastor, we thought it was bad under the former premier... Cox will go down in bermuda history as the worst premier we have ever had...she has no clue as to what is going on !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I guess we will have another voice to say "we had to deceive you "in the next election....and my guess it will be a women....

        lost all respect from the party......

        Like(0)
        Dislike(0)
  3. Somebody is making sense... says:

    I have never wanted to vote a party out of power as I do now.

    Like(0)
    Dislike(0)
  4. Joonya says:

    They 'had to deceive you' Grant.

    Like(0)
    Dislike(0)
  5. terry says:

    Build it, they will come.
    In the interum:-

    Like(0)
    Dislike(0)
  6. Mountbatten says:

    Paula Has Cash . PHC

    Like(0)
    Dislike(0)
    • Family Man says:

      Good one. But it might now be Paula Had Cash. After all that was 2008. We're now in 2012 and desperately trying to skim money out of the pension funds.

      Like(0)
      Dislike(0)
      • pepper says:

        Paula, please think about your father and what he stood for...

        Like(0)
        Dislike(0)
Chance of Rain
Friday
Chance of Rain
High 84° / Low 78°
Chance of Rain
Saturday
Chance of Rain
High 84° / Low 80°
Clear
Sunday
Clear
High 85° / Low 80°

Sign Up For Our Free Email Newsletters

email-banners-good-news-370

Latest Podcasts

Podcast: Governor On Airport, Commission, More

Podcast: Governor On Airport, Commission, More

In this latest Bernews podcast, we interview George Fergusson who will soon be stepping down as Governor.

He touches on a wide range of issues such as turning down a request to hold a Commission of Inquiry into the Tucker’s Point land matter, the airport redevelopment, the effect on Bermuda of Brexit, the British Government’s stance on slave trade reparations and more.

And Mr Fergusson re-iterated his belief that the Commission of Inquiry into issues highlighted by the Auditor General’s reports was [...]

Share via email
July 25, 2016 | 9 Comments
Podcast: MP Furbert On Same Sex Marriage Bill

Podcast: MP Furbert On Same Sex Marriage Bill

Bermuda is on “good grounds” regarding same sex marriage, based on what other countries around the world have done, according to MP Wayne Furbert.

Mr Furbert — who tabled amendments to ensure marriage was enshrined as being between a man and a woman — was responding during a Bernews podcast interview to a statement from the Human Rights Commission.

He refuted that for many – the recent referendum failed to attract 50 per cent of those eligible to vote – same sex [...]

Share via email
July 14, 2016 | 53 Comments
Podcast: Ross Webber & Sean Moran Of BDA

Podcast: Ross Webber & Sean Moran Of BDA

What does International Business means to Bermuda and what role does the Bermuda Business Development Agency [BDA] play? That is the question we looked at during our most recent Podcast, where Chris Famous sits down with Ross Webber and the Sean Moran of the BDA.

Ross Webber joined the BDA as CEO in 2014, having served as a Board Director since inception, while Sean Moran is a Business Development Manager at the BDA, a role he has held since August 2014.

The BDA [...]

Share via email
July 7, 2016 | 0 Comments
Podcast: MP Leah Scott On Politics & More

Podcast: MP Leah Scott On Politics & More

OBA MP Leah Scott was aware of talks between former Tourism Minister Shawn Crockwell and the PLP about forming a coalition government, she said in the latest Bernews Podcast.

And asked if she supported Mr Crockwell, who has since resigned from Cabinet, she said: “Yes.” Asked how she knew, she said she was friends with Mr Crockwell and they talked about it.

Asked if it was something she would have joined, Ms Scott said: “If it was something that could have been [...]

Share via email
June 23, 2016 | 20 Comments
Podcast: Casino Gaming Commission Director

Podcast: Casino Gaming Commission Director

In the latest Bernews podcast, the executive director of the Bermuda Casino Gaming Commission says using Singaporean gaming legislation as a model has slowed down the process of bringing a casino to Bermuda.

Richard Shuetz told Bernews that the Commission had drafted more than 40 amendments to the legislation that was passed in 2014 and that he was talking to the new Tourism Minister, Michael Fahy, about the issue.

“I have actually made a large number of changes. The selection of the Singapore [...]

Share via email
May 30, 2016 | 19 Comments