Think Tank: ‘Onshoring’ Reinsurance

March 14, 2012

The Washington DC office of the Heartland Institute think tank yesterday [Mar.13] hosted a major symposium on “onshoring” catastrophe reinsurance reserves now held in off-shore business domiciles including Bermuda.

The Illinois-based Heartland Institute has been part of ongoing efforts to transform the District of Columbia into “Bermuda On The Potomac” — an onshore domicile for leading American re/insurers.

“In the past decade, tornadoes, hurricanes, floods, wildfires, and other major natural disasters have done record amounts of damage in all regions of the country,” said the Heartland Institute in a statement issued this week. “To assure they can pay claims following these disasters, insurers and reinsurers must maintain ‘catastrophe reserves’.”

“Because of the way US law treats these reserves, nearly all of them are currently located in offshore jurisdictions like Bermuda, the United Kingdom, Switzerland and Germany.”

The District of Columbia’s Congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton has proposed a bill that would encourage companies to keep these reserves in Washington, transforming the US capital into what’s been described as “Bermuda on the Potomac.”

Washington DC’s non-voting Congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton

The Heartland Institute has in the past consulted for both the Association of Bermuda Insurers and Reinsurers [ABIR] and a subsidiary of Hamilton-based Renaissance Re.

Panellists at yesterday’s symposium were:

  • Rep. Eleanor Holmes Norton (Democrat,DC)
  • Rep. David Rivera (Republican, Florida)
  • Lawrence Mirel, Former Commissioner of Insurance, Securities and Banking, District of Columbia
  • Matt Wulf, Vice President, State Relations, Reinsurance Association of America
  • Eli Lehrer, Vice President, The Heartland Institute

Rep. Norton’s legislation would see the District of Columbia become a domestic tax haven for if her recently proposed legislation is passed by the US Congress.

The bill would designate the US capital as a special jurisdiction where reserves and related investments from insurers and reinsurers could be set aside free of federal taxes.

A rough year in the United States for natural catastrophes makes the District of Columbia National Disaster Insurance Protection Act particularly timely, Rep. Norton said in a statement when she introduced the legislation last October.

“Retaining funds here in the US would fuel both the local and US economies, would provide the protection of US laws for individuals and businesses with property and casualty insurance and would protect US taxpayers, who would otherwise likely have to pick up the tab if there were a failure in reserve fund availability,” she said.

Congress’ ultimate control of district affairs is usually a sore point for local officials. However, in this case, it could bring a new advantage, said Lawrence Mirel, a former commissioner of the district’s Department of Insurance, Securities & Banking who worked on the legislation.

The bill requires companies with reserves held in the district to maintain a physical office. The district government could also impose an excise fee — as non-US jurisdictions do.

“The best way to look at it is to look at what it did for Bermuda,” said Mr. Mirel, a lawyer with Wiley Rein LLP.

Limiting the tax deductibility of reinsurance premiums paid by US-based, foreign-owned insurers to non-US-based affiliates has been a recurrent issue in Washington.

Proposals to address what many see as a tax disparity that benefits non-US-owned companies, many of them based in Bermuda,  has resurfaced recently in both a bill introduced by Massachusetts Congressman Richard Neal and in Obama administration budget proposal.

The Norton measure is a welcome fresh take, said R.J. Lehmann, deputy director of the Heartland Institute’s Centre on Finance, Insurance, and Real Estate.

“While further investigation is warranted into how the DC catastrophe reserve accounts would interact with the tax code, with state and international regulation and with accounting rules, we think this approach offers great promise for fostering a property insurance system that is both affordable and risk-based,” Mr. Lehmann said.

While Rep. Norton is the ranking Democrat on the House Subcommittee on Economic Development, Public Buildings, and Emergency Management, she is a nonvoting member of the minority party. She introduced a similar and unsuccessful measure in 2010.

Given the prevalence of catastrophes in 2011, however, Mr. Mirel is optimistic the new bill will attract Republican support. “We can’t do this with just her. We need to attract some other lawmakers,” he said.

In 2010 Washington DC’s chief financial officer Natwar Gandhi first proposed transforming the perpetually cash-strapped American capital into an on-shore business domicile — saying the city had the potential to become “Bermuda on the Potomac.”

“Natwar Gandhi [suggests bringing] in dollars from rich corporations, namely banks and insurance companies who currently park millions of dollars abroad in island tax havens,” reported “Washington Herald” columnist Herbert Jaffe last year. “Gandhi wants to change federal tax laws and make DC ‘Bermuda on the Potomac’.

“Sounds reasonable. ‘The financial centre of the country is in Washington now’, Gandhi tells me. ‘All the trading can be done in New York, but the decisions are made here’ …”

“So why not make the capital into an on-shore tax haven, asked Mr. Jaffe? Why not lure all of those Bermuda-based insurance companies and their millions back on-shore by turning the District of Columbia into a corporate-friendly zone?

“Having no vote in the House or the Senate, DC is at the mercy of our suburban neighbours,” he said by way of answering his own question.

“Every time DC floats a tax haven idea, politicians from Maryland and Virginia see it as giving the central city a competitive advantage. ‘It’s an idea we have explored in the past’, council finance chair Jack Evans says. “Maybe it’s time to do it again. I’m all for it’.”

Share via email

Read More About

Category: All, Business

Comments (3)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Joe says:

    And I understand that the PLP, and in particular the Premier, uses these people to advise her, people who are actively working to discredit and emasculate Bermuda's main line of business. Has she finally lost it, or is there something here I am not understanding?

  2. Googlybda says:

    "But Bermuda is not a tax haven!"
    This is not just a failure of our government its a failure of our business community to create a sustainable economy and not one that leaches off other country' taxes.


Latest Podcasts

Podcast: MP Furbert On Same Sex Marriage Bill

Podcast: MP Furbert On Same Sex Marriage Bill

Bermuda is on “good grounds” regarding same sex marriage, based on what other countries around the world have done, according to MP Wayne Furbert.

Mr Furbert — who tabled amendments to ensure marriage was enshrined as being between a man and a woman — was responding during a Bernews podcast interview to a statement from the Human Rights Commission.

He refuted that for many – the recent referendum failed to attract 50 per cent of those eligible to vote – same sex [...]

Share via email
July 14, 2016 | 53 Comments
Podcast: Ross Webber & Sean Moran Of BDA

Podcast: Ross Webber & Sean Moran Of BDA

What does International Business means to Bermuda and what role does the Bermuda Business Development Agency [BDA] play? That is the question we looked at during our most recent Podcast, where Chris Famous sits down with Ross Webber and the Sean Moran of the BDA.

Ross Webber joined the BDA as CEO in 2014, having served as a Board Director since inception, while Sean Moran is a Business Development Manager at the BDA, a role he has held since August 2014.

The BDA [...]

Share via email
July 7, 2016 | 0 Comments
Podcast: MP Leah Scott On Politics & More

Podcast: MP Leah Scott On Politics & More

OBA MP Leah Scott was aware of talks between former Tourism Minister Shawn Crockwell and the PLP about forming a coalition government, she said in the latest Bernews Podcast.

And asked if she supported Mr Crockwell, who has since resigned from Cabinet, she said: “Yes.” Asked how she knew, she said she was friends with Mr Crockwell and they talked about it.

Asked if it was something she would have joined, Ms Scott said: “If it was something that could have been [...]

Share via email
June 23, 2016 | 20 Comments
Podcast: Casino Gaming Commission Director

Podcast: Casino Gaming Commission Director

In the latest Bernews podcast, the executive director of the Bermuda Casino Gaming Commission says using Singaporean gaming legislation as a model has slowed down the process of bringing a casino to Bermuda.

Richard Shuetz told Bernews that the Commission had drafted more than 40 amendments to the legislation that was passed in 2014 and that he was talking to the new Tourism Minister, Michael Fahy, about the issue.

“I have actually made a large number of changes. The selection of the Singapore [...]

Share via email
May 30, 2016 | 19 Comments
Podcast: Crockwell On Resignation, Politics, More

Podcast: Crockwell On Resignation, Politics, More

Former Tourism and Transport Minister Shawn Crockwell approached some members of the PLP about forming a coalition government after he quit the OBA Cabinet, Bernews can reveal.

In the latest Bernews podcast – an in-depth interview spanning over 45 minutes — Mr Crockwell said it had been wrong to suggest he was considering crossing the floor of the House of Assembly to join the PLP.

However, in the interview he adds: “I do have quite a few friends on the other side [...]

Share via email
May 17, 2016 | 76 Comments