Video: Wage Commission Press Conference

May 13, 2021 | 3 Comments

Minister of Labour Jason Hayward held a press conference today [May 13] regarding the Wage Commission Report, saying that “this Government is confident that as we move toward establishing a minimum wage in alignment with a living wage regime, it will improve the lives of many by ensuring that they receive fair and just wages allowing individuals and their families to cover their basic needs.”

Minister Hayward’s full statement follows below:

Good day to all members of the media and the listening public.

The public is aware of the challenges facing many hard-working Bermudians who struggling daily to ensure their family’s basic needs are met. With that in mind, this Government is confident that as we move toward establishing a minimum wage in alignment with a living wage regime, it will improve the lives of many by ensuring that they receive fair and just wages allowing individuals and their families to cover their basic needs.

I am pleased to announce that we are one step closer to that goal.

To that end, the Wage Commission [the “Commission”] was established by the Employment [Wage Commission] Act 2019 [the “Act”] as a result of a Parliamentary Joint Select Committee on the establishment of a living and minimum wage regime. Its function is to “conduct such studies, reviews and analyses as necessary and make recommendations on the minimum hourly wage and the living wage rates to be prescribed” by the Minister of Labour.

The Commission, which functions as an independent authority, is chaired by Mr. Cordell Riley and consists of eight members, including ex-officio representatives from the Ministries responsible for Finance and Labour.

On behalf of the Ministry of Labour, I give my sincere thanks to the Wage Commission for completing and delivering to the Government the first report that provides recommendations on establishing a minimum wage in alignment with their responsibilities as set out in Part 3 of the Employment [Wage Commission] Act 2019.

At this time, I welcome Mr. Riley to say a few words and speak to the document’s findings.

Mr Cordell Riley’s remarks follow below:

Thank you, Minister Hayward, and Good morning Bermuda.

The Commission began its work in earnest last February in establishing a minimum wage in the first instance and a liveable wage, secondly, for Bermuda.

At the onset, the coronavirus pandemic was unfolding. Its devastating effects have been laid bare. While some may have considered this an inappropriate time to introduce a minimum wage, that was not the position taken by the Economist Magazine in its March 2021 edition. They felt that the one lesson that Western Governments should have learned, coming out of this pandemic, is the need to top up the wages of lower-income workers. Bermuda can also learn from that lesson.

Most modern, developed countries have a minimum/living wage regime. More than 90% of countries designated as International Labour Organization [ILO] member states currently have a statutory wage scheme of some sort. Many evidence-based documents have outlined the many benefits realised by employers and employees in countries where a minimum and/or living wage has been instituted. Among the more developed nations of the world, Bermuda is among the few that does not have a minimum wage, and the goal is to remove us from that list.

According to some reports, studying the impact of minimum wages on economies is the most researched topic in all of economics. No matter what side of the debate you are on, you will find many studies to support your viewpoint. The Commission remained focused on its task of recommending a minimum wage for Bermuda with the knowledge that a minimum wage will assist in:

  • Promoting fair compensation for employees
  • Improving an individual’s quality of life;
  • Preventing further exploitation of workers;
  • Preventing working families that are below the poverty line from receiving what many would consider unliveable wages; and
  • Improving the purchasing power of individuals.

One of the working definitions of poverty, related to wages, is that a person is considered to be in poverty if they earn less than half the median wage rate. It is deemed unconscionable that this is the case in an affluent country like Bermuda. It is therefore essential that an appropriate minimum wage be established.

When making recommendations for a living wage, which the legislation defines as the income necessary for an employee and their household to enjoy “a socially acceptable standard of living,” the Commission will consider essential costs such as food, housing, clothing, medical needs, childcare, and transportation.
One of the lessons learned from other countries during the pandemic was the need to top-up the lowest-paid workers’ wages in the community. With the establishment of a minimum and liveable wage, Bermuda can benefit from the lessons learned in these countries.

The Commission reviewed a sample of countries to understand the range of minimum wages applied. I must note that Switzerland has the highest minimum wage at $24.76BD while Turks and Caicos have the lowest at $6.25BD. However, when comparing the cost of living of those countries sampled to Bermuda’s, all had a lower cost of living than Bermuda.

In addition to the Low Income Thresholds’ report conducted by the Bermuda Department of Statistics, and the Joint Select Report of Parliament, the Commission relied heavily on reports produced by the ILO, particularly its report on Minimum Wage Systems [2014]. The Joint Select report recommended, as some of the ILO member states, using or applying a fixed percentage of the median income. As opposed to the average, the median income is frequently used as extremely high or low incomes do not distort it.

Having concluded the first report, the Commission recommended three options for a minimum wage, depending on what is expected to be achieved.

Option 1: A minimum wage of $13.19, [$13.20] which is 42% of the median hourly wage in 2019 and, due to no increase in inflation, likely in 2020 as well. This is the wage floor option, with many employers in the target sectors, such as the Hospitality sector, indicating that many can already meet this level.

Option 2: A minimum wage of $15.71 [$15.75], which is 50% of the median hourly wage. This option is at the poverty level threshold, thus setting a wage level that is not below the poverty level. This provides workers with greater wage dignity and begins taking those at the lower end out of poverty. This rate would be a stretch for some employers, but early indications are that most would be able to make that stretch.

Option 3: A minimum wage of $17.28 [$17.30], which is 55% of the median hourly wage. At this level, the wage is set at the lower bounds of a liveable wage. A minimum wage at this level would pave the way for the transition to a liveable wage. However, some feedback received by the Commission was that some employers would have to take measures to achieve this wage while others may go out of business altogether. Thank You.

Minister Hayward’s closing remarks follow below:

Again, the Government thanks the Commission for the work it has done thus far and will await receipt of the Commission’s second report on a living wage. After which the Government will review the recommendations and considerations contained in the reports with an aim to table in Parliament a wage bill that will establish a statutory minimum wage in alignment with a living wage regime.

In closing, I want to remind everyone that each of us has a role to play in stopping the spread of the coronavirus. Follow Public Health guidelines, wear a mask, practice good hand hygiene, maintain physical distance and download the WeHealth Bermuda app.

Do the research, talk with your doctor and make an informed decision about getting the COVID-19 vaccine.
Thank you

At this time, I welcome questions from the media.

Read More About

Category: All, Business, News, Politics, Videos

Comments (3)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. wahoo says:

    I read a bit but not all. Did anyone hear what the plan is to fix the economy? You cannot guarantee a minimum anything without having an economy that is working and we do not have that. Mr. Hayward and his party have a lot of hard work to undo and it is their hard work because they got us here.

  2. Vortex says:

    Rough timing Jason, haven’t you noticed businesses folding everywhere?

    But then that’s all you’ve got, one trick pony union man.

    How about attracting some job creating expats, or at least retaining the ones we’ve got.

  3. sandgrownan says:

    If you paid the wage commission the proposed minimum wage, it would be too much. Three years to work out a percentage?

    “Unfortunately, the real minimum wage is always zero, regardless of the laws, and that is the wage that many workers receive in the wake of the creation or escalation of a government-mandated minimum wage, because they lose their jobs or fail to find jobs when they enter the labor force. Making it illegal to pay less than a given amount does not make a worker’s productivity worth that amount—and, if it is not, that worker is unlikely to be employed”

Leave a Reply