Minister Roban’s Statement on Tucker’s Point

February 4, 2011

[Updated with video] This afternoon [Feb 4] Minister of Environment, Planning and Infrastructure Strategy Walter Roban spoke at a press conference in reference to the planned development at Tucker’s Point Hotel, saying that “the Ministry of Environment, Planning and Infrastructure Strategy would also like to pledge its support for this development project through the provision of a Special Development Order.”

Minister Roban went on to say that “SDO’s are regarded, by their critics, as a way to circumvent the normal planning process, but they are, in fact, an important tool for the Minister to respond to strategic, national issues and to the development needs of the day.”

“The Tucker’s Point Resort Residential Development is one of those developments which urgently needs an SDO. I wish to highlight that the Ministry is handling this in an extremely transparent manner, including; tabling it in the Legislature for debate; and granting In Principle Approval only, rather than Final Approval, thereby requiring the developer to satisfy the Department of Planning before Final Approval is granted.”

Minister Roban’s full remarks follow below:

Good Afternoon Everyone,

‘Thank you’ Minister Minors for getting right to the heart of the matter: this hotel development is indeed a National Priority.

And as such, the Ministry of Environment, Planning and Infrastructure Strategy would also like to pledge its support for this development project through the provision of a Special Development Order (or SDO).

SDOs are used to achieve a national priority that could not otherwise be met under the regular Planning Regime. They are not aberrations; they are duly provided for in our legislation.

Under Section 15 of the Development and Planning Act 1974, the Minister (being the Minister “responsible for planning”) has the authority to make an SDO that grants planning permission for a development as specified in such Order.

An SDO enables the Minister to respond to development needs that are of strategic, national importance or priority, and for which the Development Applications Board does not have the authority to grant planning permission.

The key is how we use them.

SDO’s are regarded, by their critics, as a way to circumvent the normal planning process, but they are, in fact, an important tool for the Minister to respond to strategic, national issues and to the development needs of the day.

The Tucker’s Point Resort Residential Development is one of those developments which urgently needs an SDO.

I wish to highlight that the Ministry is handling this in an extremely transparent manner, including; tabling it in the Legislature for debate; and granting In Principle Approval only, rather than Final Approval, thereby requiring the developer to satisfy the Department of Planning before Final Approval is granted.

I also want to underscore the very stringent conditions that have been attached to this particular SDO – conditions that are designed to balance the economic needs of hotel development with the environmental needs of Bermuda.

Environmentally, Tucker’s Point is very important, containing important woodland areas and habitats of national significance with one of the highest percentages of native and endemic tree species per acre. The contiguous woodland areas on the property are among the largest on the Island and it is home to the last stand of mature native Yellow Wood trees in Bermuda and provides the seed source to propagate the recovery of this species. The property also contains extensive cave systems due to its karst geology and these systems are only partially surveyed.

The Department of Planning, the Department of Conservation Services and the Sustainable Development Unit have all contributed to the definition of the conditions attached to this SDO.

For example: all existing or newly discovered cave features on the proposed development sites will require a subterranean topographical survey be completed by a qualified cave survey specialist to geo-reference the cave voids for terrestrial development potential considerations. All mapped caves, cave features and new caves will require a minimum setback buffer of 30 feet for all structures and excavation.

Additionally, any identified critical habitat or existing mature specimen endemic, native or ornamental plants must be recorded; and these sites and plants must be protected and provided with an adequate setback buffer.

A landscape principle of 40% endemics, 30% Natives, 20% non-invasive ornamentals and 10% will be applied to each proposed lot.

The majority of areas subject to this Order will require a Conservation Management Plan prepared on an area wide basis.

Additionally, as a compensatory measure, Mangrove Lake together with two areas comprising 7.45 acres and 1.64 acres respectively on the western and northwestern sides of White Crest Hill, are proposed to be donated to the Government for conservation management purposes.

In closing, I want to thank the technical teams at the Departments of Planning and Conservation Services for their careful attention to issues that had to be addressed. The conditions crafted in this Order have been done with the benefit of their advice, knowledge and expertise to ensure an effective balance between development and environmental interests. We are all sensitive to the special nature of many areas within Castle Harbour and this specially crafted SDO goes very far to satisfy this priority.

Thank you.

Read More About

Category: All, Environment, News

Comments (15)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Call as it is says:

    Money money money
    go figure

  2. Honestly? says:

    Does anyone believe that these PLP politician are writing these speaches? None of these persons seem literate enough. The style is the same for everyone. I think they use overseas consultants to prepare everything.

    • One Love says:

      Sorry Honestly, but who really cares about who writes the speeches? Forget the speech and focus on the content. Ok,maybe not, you may really get mad .

  3. One Love says:

    Where oh where did those campaign promises go… oh where oh where did they go? The one thing that the PLP have proven consistently over the past 12 years is that power in the hands of some black folk can be just as destructive as power in the hands of those folk of a fairer persuasion that preceded them. I respectfully ask that you drop Progressive and Labour from your name.

  4. Sad Indeed says:

    TP have already announced financial hardship when they laid off staff. Extending the hotel makes no sense as it is rarely fully occupied. Building more fractionals, timeshares and residential houses makes no sense when there are others (ie reefs and Newstead) sitting empty around the Island. Granting an SDO to carve up one of the last remaining large scall hillsides is CRIMINAL. Further, that hillside is home to one of the most extensive cave systems in Bermuda showing that the minister, TP and the Government have absolutely NO CARE OR CONCERN for the welfare of future Bermudians, nor the sustainability of the Island. The last time TP found caves during development, they merely filled them in with ruble and said nothing. My poor dear children, what type of Bermuda will they be living in thirty years down the road compliments of this governments continuiously incompetent decisions?

    • One Love says:

      Excellent stuff

    • Sara says:

      WELL SAID! This is absolutely CRIMINAL building. Empty shit all over the island and they want to build more???? Are we in crazy town???? Why are they expanding when their hotel is like a ghost town? What in the world is TRULY going on here?

  5. Joe says:

    Really, who cares anymore?
    Sad, but I find I don’t.

    • One Love says:

      It’s cool that you don’t care Joe,remove yourself from the discussion and leave to those that do.

    • johhnyboy says:

      Adios Joe..Slip into darkness will you..

  6. lloyd says:

    soon bermudians will not be able to turn into paynters road because it will be a gated community

  7. Letariatpro says:

    Nothing more than a sham to bail out the fat cats at HSBC. If the hotel rooms are not full now, they will not be after. They are just trying to sell off more Bermudian land to rich foreigners so they can make their dept payments and run.

    Man someone really must have posted a giant billboard on North Rock that says “Suckers due South”.

  8. We look stupid says:

    If this SDO goes through – Bermuda will look like the most uneducated country in the world. Why would you give a failing resort the means to build further? Especially when our tourism model DOES NOT WORK. AND everywhere else in the world is cutting back on real estate risk exposure while we are charging straight ahead with it.

    When will our Goverment and residents wake up and stop letting things like this go through with no push back to say NO?!

    I’m sure it probably helps that HSBC’s CEO is Dr Brown’s brother…

  9. Sara says:

    It is all too obvious that once again we are not being told the full story!
    At least now even the regular laymen get that this is all a sham. The PLP is losing support fast and furious. Not that they won’t get re-elected, but I think they are going to be under a LARGE amount of stress from their supporters. This SDO is going against EVERYTHING they say in regard to “protecting Bermudians”. This is simply a case of building for the sake of building and is more of a bailout smokescreen. If you build they will come? No, they won’t because the tourists see “they paved paradise to put up a parking lot” That was all Bermuda had, her natural beauty and now it is covered in concrete, is it really a surprise the tourists don’t want to come here?

    • johhnyboy says:

      Protecting Bermudians has never been the mandate of these eltist..Check the pic with Minors, Roban and Furbert and the Tuckers Point cartel.. Just proud to be there.. So proud!!!. Pathetic sell outs!!!